When deciding on warehouse security, businesses are faced with a crucial question: should they invest in a manned security presence or opt for a modern warehouse CCTV system? Both approaches aim to deter theft, protect assets, and ensure the safety of staff and property, but each comes with its own set of advantages, limitations, and costs.
At Active CCTV, we’re often asked which option is more effective for warehouses. In this blog, we’ll break down the key differences between manned security and CCTV for warehouses, comparing costs, coverage, reliability, and long-term benefits.
The Role of Warehouse Security
Warehouses typically store high-value goods, equipment, and materials, making them a frequent target for theft, vandalism, and unauthorised access. Effective security is essential to minimise risk, protect inventory, and maintain a safe working environment. The right security solution can also help businesses reduce insurance premiums and improve compliance with health and safety standards.
What Is Warehouse CCTV?
Warehouse CCTV refers to a network of professionally installed cameras that monitor and record activity across the facility. These systems can be tailored to suit your warehouse layout, providing 24/7 coverage of key areas including loading bays, entry points, storage racks, and car parks.
At Active CCTV, we design bespoke warehouse CCTV systems with features such as:
- High-definition video footage
- Infrared night vision
- Remote access via mobile or desktop
- Motion detection and alerts
- Cloud storage and real-time playback
Warehouse CCTV is increasingly seen as a powerful, cost-effective solution for modern security needs.
What Is Manned Security?
Manned security refers to trained security personnel who are physically present on-site. These professionals can patrol the premises, check vehicles, manage access control, and respond to incidents in real time.
While the presence of a guard may serve as a strong visual deterrent, it comes at a significant cost and can be limited in terms of coverage and consistency.
Cost Comparison
Warehouse CCTV
Installing a commercial CCTV system for a warehouse involves an upfront cost for the cameras, installation, and setup. However, the system requires minimal maintenance and incurs very low ongoing costs once in place. Remote monitoring can also be outsourced or handled in-house.
Manned Security
Hiring full-time security guards can be extremely expensive. When factoring in salaries, benefits, training, and shift coverage (especially for 24/7 protection), manned security can cost thousands of pounds each month, far more than a CCTV system over the same period.
Verdict: Warehouse CCTV provides excellent value for money, especially for long-term security planning.
Coverage and Reliability
Warehouse CCTV Systems
- Provide 24/7 surveillance with no breaks, sick days, or distractions
- Can monitor multiple zones simultaneously
- Store footage for evidence and insurance purposes
- Work even in low light or no light with infrared cameras
Manned Security
- Coverage depends on human attention and presence
- Guards can only be in one place at a time
- Vulnerable to fatigue, distraction, or being overpowered
- Lack of video evidence, unless combined with CCTV
Verdict: CCTV systems deliver continuous, reliable surveillance with a much broader field of view.
Response Time and Incident Handling
Warehouse CCTV
- Can include remote monitoring with alerts triggered by motion detection
- Allows for immediate response from security personnel or police
- Provides visual evidence to support investigations or insurance claims
Manned Security
- Can intervene in real-time if an incident occurs on their watch
- Able to physically respond, de-escalate situations, or detain trespassers
Verdict: A combination of warehouse CCTV and a response plan (e.g. remote monitoring linked to rapid response teams) often proves more efficient and cost-effective than solely relying on manned security.
Deterrence Factor
Warehouse CCTV
Visible CCTV cameras act as a strong deterrent. Most intruders are less likely to attempt break-ins when they see active surveillance.
Manned Security
Uniformed guards are also a strong deterrent, particularly in high-risk areas or during peak threat times.
Verdict: Both options deter crime, but warehouse CCTV offers a consistent presence without downtime.
Scalability and Flexibility
Warehouse CCTV
- Easily scalable, add or reposition cameras as your site expands
- Integrates with alarm systems, access control, and ANPR
- Ideal for multi-site businesses with centralised monitoring
Manned Security
- Scaling up requires hiring more staff
- Managing multiple shifts or locations can become logistically challenging
Verdict: CCTV offers greater scalability and flexibility for growing warehouse operations.
Compliance and Documentation
Warehouse CCTV
- Provides documented video evidence
- Supports internal investigations and audits
- Helps meet health and safety regulations
- Can be used to resolve disputes or delivery discrepancies
Manned Security
- May log incidents manually
- No video record unless used in tandem with CCTV
Verdict: CCTV offers more reliable and accessible documentation.
Final Thoughts: Which Is More Effective?
While both manned security and CCTV have their place in warehouse security strategies, warehouse CCTV systems offer greater coverage, consistency, cost-effectiveness, and flexibility. For most businesses, a modern CCTV warehouse setup, possibly combined with alarm systems or occasional on-site security, delivers the best balance of protection and value.
With advanced features like remote monitoring, motion detection, and high-definition recording, warehouse security cameras from Active CCTV help you protect your assets 24/7, reduce costs, and improve your operational oversight.
Secure Your Warehouse with Active CCTV
If you’re weighing up your options for warehouse security, talk to our team today. At Active CCTV, we offer tailored solutions using industry-leading technology to help safeguard your premises. Call 01492 547997 or email info@active-cctv.co.uk to arrange a free site survey and quote.
